Where to Sell Collectibles: Platforms, Charges and Payouts Compared

Where to sell collectibles depends on three things: who buys that kind of item, what the platform takes from each sale, and how the payout reaches you. We read the seller pages of eBay, Etsy, StockX, Craigslist, Mercari and TCGplayer on 7 October 2026 and set what those platforms publish side by side. Every figure below is what the platform itself lists, or our own arithmetic from it, not a forecast.
- eBay: according to eBay Seller Center, a final value charge of 13.6% in most categories and 13.25% for trading cards (each up to $7,500 per item), plus $0.30 or $0.40 per order.
- Etsy: according to Etsy’s selling page, a $0.20 listing charge and a 6.5% transaction charge on the sale price.
- StockX: according to its seller program page, a base transaction charge of 9.0% at Level 1, falling to 7.0% at Level 5.
- Craigslist: according to its posting fees page, free postings except a list of categories, including $5 for by-dealer for-sale postings in the US.
Which platforms suit which kind of collectible?
The right platform is the one where buyers for your kind of item already shop: card buyers use card marketplaces, sneaker buyers use sneaker platforms, and everything else goes to a general marketplace. eBay is general, with a fee table that runs from trading cards to guitars to heavy equipment, and Facebook’s own page describes Marketplace as a place to buy and sell items locally or shipped.
The niche platforms narrow the audience on purpose. TCGplayer is a marketplace for trading card games, and its seller page says you can digitize Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards with image recognition. StockX, according to its help center, offers a Verified Marketplace for new or unworn items, a Listings Marketplace for used or unique items, and a Live Marketplace for live shopping.
Toys have their own routes, and our guide on where to resell Mattel items covers Mattel pieces specifically. Other platforms exist; the figures and rules in this article come only from platforms whose own pages we could read and quote.
What does eBay keep from a collectible sale?
eBay keeps a final value charge of 13.6% of the total sale in most categories (exceptions apply), plus $0.30 on orders of $10 or less or $0.40 on orders over $10, according to eBay Seller Center. The same page says trading cards carry 13.25% and sneakers over $150 carry 8%, with no per-order charge on those sneakers. The 13.6% and 13.25% rates apply up to $7,500 per item.
It’s free to list. You’ll only pay a fee if your item sells.
That line is eBay’s own summary of its structure. The page adds that listing more than 250 items per month brings a $0.35 insertion charge per listing. The percentage applies to the total amount of the sale, including shipping and sales tax, so a $100 total works out to $13.60 plus $0.40 in most categories.
What do StockX and Etsy charge sellers?
StockX charges a base transaction fee on its Verified Marketplace, and its seller program page lists 9.0% at Level 1 and 7.0% at Level 5. The page says Level 2 needs 12 sales or $1,500 USD in a quarter, and Level 5 needs 800 sales or $100,000 USD. It also says the Listings and Live marketplaces carry no seller fees, and it gives no payment processing rate.
Etsy’s selling page lists a $0.20 listing charge, good for four months or until the item sells, and a 6.5% transaction charge on the sale price including the shipping price you set. It also lists a 15% offsite ads charge that applies only to sales made through those ads, and says fees vary with the location of your bank account.
The table works each listed charge through on a $100 total, using our arithmetic. Platforms change their charges, so treat these figures as a snapshot, not a promise. For sneakers, our guide on where and how to resell sneakers goes further.
Platform and category Charge as published On a $100 total (our arithmetic) Page read on 7 October 2026 eBay, most categories 13.6% plus $0.40 per order over $10 $13.60 + $0.40 = $14.00 eBay Seller Center eBay, trading cards 13.25% plus $0.40 per order over $10 $13.25 + $0.40 = $13.65 eBay Seller Center StockX Verified, Level 1 9.0% base transaction fee $9.00 StockX seller program page StockX Verified, Level 5 7.0% base transaction fee $7.00 StockX seller program page Etsy $0.20 listing plus 6.5% transaction $0.20 + $6.50 = $6.70, listing and transaction only Etsy selling page Craigslist, by owner, other than vehicles Free $0.00 Craigslist posting fees page Craigslist, by dealer, for sale (US) $5 per posting $5.00 Craigslist posting fees page How do you find out what a collectible sold for?
You find out what a collectible sold for by looking at completed sales on the platform you plan to use, because an asking price only shows what a seller hopes for. Both eBay and TCGplayer publish reference figures of their own.
TCGplayer’s seller page says you can enter prices by hand or match them to its data points, such as Lowest Listing, Last Sold Listing and Market Price. eBay’s trading cards page describes a Price Guide built on “26+ years of transaction data” and an eBay market value that “estimates a card’s value at that particular moment in time”.
Treat every one of those numbers as a snapshot with a date on it. Our Pokémon card valuation guide goes into card prices in more depth.
How and when does the money reach you?
The money reaches you through each platform’s own payout system, and the timing differs from one to the next. StockX’s help center says payouts are issued as a lump sum each evening, at approximately 7:00 PM ET.
Mercari’s payouts help page says you can cash out a balance by Instant Pay, which has a $3 flat fee per withdrawal and a $600 monthly limit, or by direct deposit, which is free and typically arrives within 5 business days. It also says a $2 fee applies only to failed withdrawal transactions.
TCGplayer’s seller page says bank verification takes 1 to 3 business days of micro-deposits before you can start receiving payments. StockX’s selling article adds that you have two business days to ship an item to StockX for verification once a purchase is confirmed.
Is selling in person simpler than selling online?
Selling in person is simpler on shipping, because the item changes hands on the spot, but it limits you to buyers who can reach you. Craigslist’s posting fees page says all postings are free except a list of categories, and that list includes $5 for by-dealer for-sale postings in the US, so an individual’s collectible posting is not on it unless it is a car, truck, RV or motorcycle.
Local collectible shops and comic shops are the other in-person route. A shop makes its own offer, so ask what it pays before you carry a box in. A flea market is a third route, so ask the organiser about any table charge before you book. For any meetup, pick a public place and confirm the payment before the item leaves your hands.
What makes a collectible listing easier to buy from?
A listing that is easy to buy from shows the item’s condition honestly, with photos that back up the description. eBay’s trading cards page asks for multiple clear images of the front, the back, any significant blemishes and any grading labels, and suggests a white backdrop, no flash and soft, diffused lighting.
Packing matters as much as the photos. The same page says eBay standard envelope shipments get protection for single cards valued up to $20 and multiple cards up to $50, and that raw and graded cards over $250 go through eBay’s Authenticity Guarantee. It also says to buy signature confirmation for cards valued over $750.
TCGplayer’s seller page suggests bubble mailers or secure envelopes, and for fragile pieces we would pack as if the box will be thrown around, because a carrier does not know what is inside. More on collecting is in the collectibles articles on our blog.





